轰击不平等:涂鸦创作与空间正义（英文）Bombing Inequality:Graffiti Writing and Spatial Justice
白龙
摘要(Abstract)：
本研究质疑了涂鸦创作，尤其是签名和大规模涂鸦，被普遍视为无意义破坏行为的观点。本文主张，涂鸦是一种具有内在政治含义的表达形式。借助空间正义的概念以及雅克·朗西埃的哲学，本研究展示了涂鸦如何在商业垄断公共空间可见性的情况下，重新夺回城市中的可见性，并挑战现代城市中自我表达机会分配的不平等。尽管涂鸦创作者普遍否认政治动机，他们的行为仍可被解读为更广泛社会—空间冲突中的抵抗表现。本研究将涂鸦置于政治艺术、空间商品化和日常抵抗的讨论框架中，提出一种规范性视角，将城市签名的艺术视为重新定义“发声共同体”的实践活动。
关键词(KeyWords)： 涂鸦创作;空间正义;公共空间;抵抗;朗西埃;政治艺术
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 白龙
参考文献(References)：
- "§1-05 Regulated Uses:NYC Parks."28 Nov.2024.
- Agence France-Presse."Hong Kongers Picnic to Avoid Covid-Tracing App."France 24 8 Feb.2022.24 Nov.2022.
- Bacharach,Sondra."Street Art and Consent."The British Journal of Aesthetics 55.4(2015):481-495.
- Baker,Laura E.“Public Sites versus Public Sights:The Progressive Response to Outdoor Advertising and the Commercialization of Public Space."American Quarterly 59.4(2007):1187-1213.
- Baldini,Andrea L."Identity and Interpretation of Public Artworks:A Challenge to Intentionalism."Kultura-SpoleczeństwoEdukacja 8.2(2015):9-26.
- Bidadanure,Juliana."Justice Between Coexisting Generations."The Oxford Handbook of Intergenerational Ethics.Ed.Stephen M.Gardiner.Oxford:Oxford University Press,2021.505-520.
- Blair,Carole,Marsha S.Jeppeson,and Enrico Jr Pucci."Public Memorializing in Postmodernity:The Vietnam Veterans Memorial as Prototype."Quarterly Journal of Speech 77.3(1991):263-288.
- Blanché,Ulrich.Banksy:Urban Art in a Material World.Marburg:Tectum Verlag,2016.
- Booth,Martin."'Tagging Is like a Dog Peeing on a Lamppost to Define Its Territory.'"Bristol 24/7 23 Aug.2018.27 July2024.
- Boris,Good Guy."MOSES AND TAPS~(TM)-Exclusive Interview for The Grifters Journal."The Grifters Journal.29 Sept.2015.12 May 2017.
- Brighenti,Andrea."At the Wall:Graffiti Writers,Urban Territoriality,and the Public Domain."Space and Culture 13.3(2010):315-332.
- Campos,Ricardo."Graffiti Writer as Superhero."European Journal of Cultural Studies 16.2(2013):155-170.
- Dear,Michael,and Allen Scott,eds.Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society.London:Routledge,2018.
- DeTurk,Sabrina."The'Banksy Effect'and Street Art in the Middle East."SAUC-Street Art and Urban Creativity 1.2(2015):22-30.
- Ferrell,Jeff.Crimes of Style.Urban Graffiti and the Politics of Criminality.Boston,MA:Northeastern University Press,1996.Ferrell,Jeff,and Robert D.Weide."Spot Theory."City 14.1-2(2010):48-62.
- Halsey,Mark,and Alison Young."The Meanings of Graffiti and Municipal Administration."Australian&New Zealand Journal of Criminology 35.2(2002):165-186.
- Harcourt,Bernard E.Illusion of Order:The False Promise of Broken Windows Policing.Cambridge,MA:Harvard University Press,2001.
- Harvey,David.Social Justice and the City.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press,1973.
- ---."The Right to the City."New Left Review 53(2008):23-40.
- Henke,Lutz."Why We Painted over Berlin's Most Famous Graffiti."The Guardian 19 Dec.2014.The Guardian.25 Nov.2024.
- Johansson,Anna,and Stellan Vinthagen.Conceptualizing"Everyday Resistance":A Transdisciplinary Approach.New York:Routledge,2019.
- Kan,Koon-Hwee."Adolescents and Graffiti."Art Education 54.1(2001):18-23.Lefebvre,Henri.Le droitàla ville.Paris:Anthropos,1968.
- ---.Writings on Cities.Ed.Eleonore Kofman and Elizabeth Lebas.Cambridge,MA:Blackwell,1996.
- Madanipour,Ali,Mark Shucksmith,and Elizabeth Brooks."The Concept of Spatial Justice and the European Union's Territorial Cohesion."European Planning Studies 30.5(2022):807-824.
- Masnick,Mike."Permission Culture Gone Mad:Worries About Proper License For'Balcony Singing'Lead Collection Society To Say It's Okay,You Can Sing."Techdirt.20 Mar.2020.28 Nov.2024.
- permission-culture-gone-mad-worries-about-proper-license-balcony-singing-lead-collection-society-to-say-okay-you-can-sing/>.O'Hare,Maureen."Italy's Florence Bans Eating in the Street."CNN.6 Sept.2018.28 Nov.2024.
- Pavese,Carlotta,and Alexandru Radulescu."Meaning without Gricean Intentions."Analysis 83.4(2023):708-716.
- Purcell,Mark."Excavating Lefebvre:The Right to the City and Its Urban Politics of the Inhabitant."Geo Journal 58.2/3(2002):99-108.
- ---."Possible Worlds:Henri Lefebvre and the Right to the City."Journal of Urban Affairs 36.1(2014):141-154.
- Rancière,Jacques.Dis-Agreement:Politics and Philosophy.Trans.Julie Rose.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press,1999.
- ---.Le partage du sensible:esthétique et politique.Paris:La Fabrique,2000.
- ---.The Politics of Aesthetics:The Distribution of the Sensible.Trans.Gabriel Rockhill.London:Continuum,2004.
- Redazione.“Pisa,sitting or lying on the steps of monuments prohibited.New ordinance against degradation in the historic center."Finestre sull'Art 8 Dec.2022.28 Nov.2024.
- Ross,Sheryl Tuttle."Understanding Propaganda:The Epistemic Merit Model and Its Application to Art."Journal of Aesthetic Education 36.1(2002):16-30.
- Schatzki,Theodore R.,ed.The Site of the Social:A Philosophical Account of the Constitution of Social Life and Change.University Park:Pennsylvania State University Press,2002.
- Scott,James C.“Foreword."Conceptualizing"Everyday Resistance":A Transdisciplinary Approach.New York:Routledge,2019.ix-xi.
- Simoniti,Vid."Art as Political Discourse."The British Journal of Aesthetics 61.4(2021):559-574.
- Soja,Edward W."The City and Spatial Justice."Justice spatiale I Spatial Justice 1(2009):1-5.
- Tanke,Joseph J.Jacques Rancière:An Introduction.London and New York:Continuum,2011.
- Urist,Jakoba."Chalk Wars:Mom Ticketed for Child's Chalk Drawing in Public Park."TODAY.com 2 Aug.2012.31 July2022.
- van den Bogert,Kathrine."'If You Can Play Football,You Just Play!'The Spatial Politics of Community Football and Urban Equality in the Netherlands."Leisure Studies 43.6(2024):917-931.
- Wachsmuth,David,and Alexander Weisler."Airbnb and the Rent Gap:Gentrification through the Sharing Economy."Environment and Planning A 50.6(2018):1147-1170.
- Wilson,James Q.,and George L.Kelling."Broken Window:The Police and Neighborhood Safety."Atlantic Monthly 249.3(1982):29-38.
- "Zelle Asphaltkultur."Urban Nation.27 Sept.2023.
- Zio."Exclusive Interview with Utah&Ether,Graffiti's Bonnie&Clyde."The Hundreds.5 June 2015.8 July 2016.